Local News

Christiansen Lake Residents Brace for More Quarry Activity

Residents Received a Letter Informing Them of an Upcoming Material Sale at the Comsat Quarry

Christiansen Lake Residents Brace for More Quarry Activity
Christiansen Lake in Summer. Photo by Colleen Coulon Love

In early November, residents of the Christiansen Lake area received a notice saying that the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) intends to issue a contract for the extraction of 10,000 cubic yards of rock material from a parcel near their homes.  KTNA’s Colleen Love has more.

audio-thumbnail
20261118Quarry Reopens
0:00
/257.952

Christiansen Lake Residents were upset to receive a letter informing them of an upcoming material sale on a property located near their homes. The owner of the site is the Department of Natural Resources (DNR).  DNR and local homeowners have had a contentious relationship regarding the proposed extraction site that many refer to as the Comsat Quarry.

Between 2017 and 2020, Christiansen Lake residents were rattled by industrial rock crushing, dynamite blasting and trucking at the materials site.  According to homeowners, the activity was disruptive and it sometimes happened late at night.  Residents complained to DNR about the noise.  They also asserted that the contractor was not complying with state regulations or environmental law.  Residents alleged that DNR was not providing adequate oversight of the contractor’s activities.  

Fed up with the situation, residents formed the Christiansen Area Lakes and Land Alliance, also known as (CALLA).  In 2022, CALLA formally proposed to DNR that the 153 acre parcel be designated as both habitat and a public recreation area.  DNR did not adopt CALLA’s proposal.  Instead, DNR felt the site should remain an active materials site. Talkeetna sits in a flood plain, and the Department asserted that rip rap from the quarry might be essential in order to save property during future emergencies

The case became a lawsuit and aspects of that lawsuit are still tied up in State Court.

According to Gunnar Knapp, President of CALLA, after receiving the letter, he called to ask how to best provide public comment. He says he was told by DNR that the Department is not soliciting public comments for the upcoming material sale.  Knapp says that, even if DNR is not required by law to gather comments, it didn’t sit well with local homeowners.

This announcement came out and it says, contact this person at DNR if you got questions and I wrote with several questions and one of the questions was,  How can the public comment? And the answer was, “We’re not taking public comment.”  I don’t know if they’re required to take public comment, but this is effecting the community. It’s a matter of good public policy.  You ought to know if you’re going to impact the community, what the community feels.  It would be a good thing to do.”

Despite the absence of a formal comment process, Knapp says residents decided to provide their feedback to DNR anyway.  

This upcoming material sale is different than the previous material sale. The sale that occurred between 2017 and 2020 was to a private individual contractor.  The upcoming sale is to the Mat-Su Borough.  Mike Campfield, Borough Engineer, says that DNR has provided some of the public’s comments to him. Standing at the edge of the river revetment, he acknowledged that, while there will likely be some disruption, he and his team are willing to work with the community.

He says the Quarry is a possible source for the Airstrip revetment project and that the Borough could incorporate some of CALLA’s concerns into any contracts that they make. Campfield says ultimately the choice of rock sourcing is up to the contractor they select. With other quarries being located in places like Butte, Chugach and Portage, using the Comsat Quarry could translate into significant cost savings when it comes to hauling rock.

Knapp says CALLA is sensitive to the ongoing erosion crisis that is happening at the river.  

“We fully understand and acknowledge that the erosion problems with the river are very serious and, not just at that airstrip site but all along the river there.  There’s a major problem to be addressed and we’re not looking to in any way to slow that down or impede that.”

But Knapp also adds a caveat.  

“We wouldn’t be making a fuss about this if it had been done right the last time.”

The Comsat Quarry material sale is scheduled to be issued to the Mat-Su Borough by the end of the month.  The contract is intended to be intermittently active for a 3-year period. 

Questions about the sale can be directed to Naelene Matsumiya at (907) 269-8560 or naelene.matsumiya@alaska.gov. 

For KTNA, I’m Colleen Love

Read More

Live KTNA 88.9 FM